Walk-In Tub Vs. Walk-In Shower: Which Is Best For You

Walk-In Tub and Walk-In Shower in Winnipeg

You’re looking for a bathroom upgrade for more excellent safety, accessibility, and style. Consider the distinctions between a walk-in tub and a walk-in shower. Which is right for you?

With Winnipeg Bathroom Renovations, we’ll explore the cost considerations, safety features, maintenance requirements, design options, and space requirements when deciding between a walk-in tub or shower.

Cost Considerations

When considering costs, you’ll want to consider the most affordable option. Generally speaking, a walk-in tub will cost more than a walk-in shower due to the installation process and materials needed.

Walk-in showers are usually smaller than walk-in tubs, requiring fewer materials and less labor for installation. However, if you need handicap-accessible features such as grab bars or additional fixtures like a seat or handheld sprayer, these can add to the overall cost of your shower.

On the other hand, walk-in tubs tend to have more bells and whistles that may drive up their price tag. Some even come with built-in jets for hydrotherapy! Either choice can be ideal for you depending on your budget, needs, and preference.

Typically, a tub can cost between $400 and $8,000 to install, and a shower can cost between $450 and $10,000 (1).

Always remember that local regulations may affect installation costs since specific codes must be met when installing certain fixtures. So remember to factor in any fees associated with these requirements when comparing prices between the two options.

Safety and Accessibility

Both options offer great accessibility, but when it comes to safety, a walk-in tub’s features can’t be beaten. It is a low threshold, and non-slip flooring makes getting in and out of the bath much more accessible for people with limited mobility. It also has built-in seating that allows them to sit as they bathe comfortably. Plus, its extra-wide door makes entering and exiting the tub safer for those who have difficulty balancing or require assistance.

A walk-in shower is also an excellent option for people with limited mobility. However, it poses substantial safety risks due to its slippery surface and lack of support or stability. Many walk-in showers need more space for someone with limited mobility to move around without feeling confined or restricted. Thus, while it offers easy access to the shower stall, it only provides more excellent safety than a walk-in tub.

When deciding between a walk-in tub vs. a shower for your bathroom remodel project, you should consider cost, safety, and accessibility concerns before making your final decision. Both options provide excellent accessibility solutions, but only one provides added safety features that might be necessary depending on your needs.

Maintenance Requirements

Maintaining a walk-in tub or shower requires regular upkeep. It’s important to know what’s involved before deciding which one is right for you. Both require cleaning with soap and water regularly. However, there are some differences between the two that should be considered when deciding.

Walk-In Tub:

  • Cleaning & Maintenance: Bathtubs must be cleaned regularly with nonabrasive cleaners and disinfectants. They may also need to be resealed periodically to keep them watertight.
  • Drains & Fittings: The drains of a walk-in tub must be checked for blockage or damage from time to time. Any fittings should be inspected regularly for signs of wear and tear.
  • Repairs & Replacement: If any parts become worn out or damaged, they may need to be replaced to ensure proper operation of the bathtub.

Walk-In Shower:

  • Cleaning & Maintenance: Walk-in showers require less maintenance than bathtubs. They don’t have any standing water or other materials that can accumulate bacteria or mold over time. They can be wiped down using a mild cleaner when necessary.
  • Drains & Fittings: Similar to bathtubs, the drains in showers should also be checked periodically for blockages or damage. Any fixtures should also be examined regularly for signs of wear and tear.
  • Repairs & Replacement: When components fail in a walk-in shower, they are usually easier and cheaper to replace than those in a bathtub due to their more straightforward construction.

Design Options

When it comes to design, there are various options for both walk-in tubs and showers, so you can select the one that fits your needs the most.

For walk-in tubs, they come in rectangular or oval shapes and with various door styles for easy entry. You can also choose from built-in features like grab bars and jets for soothing massages.

Walk-in showers offer just as much flexibility in design, from frameless sliding glass doors to low threshold designs with no steps or curbs required. You even have choices regarding the tile style inside the shower, such as classic subway tiles or geometric patterns.

Both walk-in bathtubs and showers provide a variety of customization choices, so you may make them exactly what you want them to be.

Space Requirements

Both walk-in tubs and showers require careful consideration for space requirements, as each one needs to fit into the allotted area in your bathroom.

Walk-in tubs typically range from 36″ to 60″ long and can be up to 48″ wide. They need enough room for a door to open outward, requiring additional space outside the tub. You’ll also need to account for any extra room for plumbing connections or other fixtures.

Walk-in showers require less space than a tub since they don’t have open doors. However, you’ll still need enough room on all sides to fully enter the shower without hitting the walls or fixtures nearby. The minimum size recommendation is usually 34′ x 34′, but some people may opt for larger sizes depending on their preferences and specific needs.

When it comes down to it, you’ll want to measure your bathroom accurately before deciding which bathtub or shower works best in your home. Remember that plenty of design options are available, too, so consider what style appeals most to you when making your final decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the energy efficiency ratings of walk-in tubs and walk-in showers?

Walk-in tubs and showers can both have good energy efficiency ratings. Both use less water, helping you save on your utility bills. Plus, they require less energy to heat the water than traditional tubs or showers.

How much does a professional installation typically cost?

A walk-in tub or shower installation is an expensive project. It typically costs thousands, so it’s essential to research before taking the plunge.

Can a standard tub or shower be converted into a walk-in tub or shower?

It’s possible to convert a standard tub or shower into a walk-in model. It involves making structural changes and may require professional installation.

Are there any additional features available with walk-in tubs or showers?

Yes! Many walk-in tubs and showers offer features like hydrotherapy jets, heated surfaces, and safe grab bars. It’s like having your spa at home – relaxing with the soothing massaging jets while enjoying safe accessibility.

Are there any special regulations to be followed when installing a walk-in tub or shower?

You must follow local codes when installing a walk-in tub or shower. Check with your building department for any additional requirements.


The decision is ultimately yours when choosing between a walk-in tub and a walk-in shower. Both have pros and cons that should be taken into consideration.

It’s like picking between two paths in life: each has its unique benefits and drawbacks. So take your time, weigh the options, and choose the best suits your needs. It will be worth it in the end!

Calling all homeowners seeking bathroom perfection! Reach out to Winnipeg Bathroom Renovations today and unlock the potential of your space. Our professionals are prepared to go over your particular remodeling and renovation demands.

Contact us now to explore our top-tier services and turn your bathroom dreams into reality. Your ideal bathroom is just a message away!

Learn how to choose materials for your next bathroom remodel in this link – https://winnipegbathrenovations.com/how-to-choose-materials-for-your-next-bathroom-remodel/


  1. https://www.bobvila.com/articles/tub-vs-shower/ 
Amiel Alcala

Amiel Alcala

Amiel Alcala

Amiel Alcala

Share this articles:

Related articles

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Subscribe to find out the latest articles

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar.